Winter means different things to different people. Moreover, the degree of winter conditions as you range from the tropics to higher latitudes varies immensely.
Equally, winter camping means different things to different people. It could be a hot tent in the boreal forest of Manitoba, or a mountain tent on a sub-Arctic plateau in Norway, or a tarp on a frosty January weekend in Yorkshire.
Of course there are multiple other permutations but if you are travelling in winter, more often than not there are three pieces of sleeping kit which are much less variable than the scenarios in which you might be using them – a sleeping bag, a sleeping mat and a bivvy bag.
Indeed, even when I am making hut-to-hut ski tours in Norway and fully planning on sleeping in mountain huts each night, I carry a sleeping bag, a sleeping mat and a bivvy bag. In between the huts I’m in remote country and if I can’t make it to a hut – due to bad weather or injury, then I want to be able to bivvy in the prevailing conditions, whether that’s in a snow trench covered by slabs or a snow hole dug into a bank. Hence I need sleeping kit which is up to the job. Furthermore, sometimes we might plan to dig a more elaborate snow palace if there is no hut in a location convenient to our journey.
Even when my friends and I go on hot-tenting trips in the boreal forest, where we have a canvas tent and a wood-burning stove, we still take sleeping bags, bivvy bags and sleeping mats. A critical point is that the sleeping bag is rated for the expected external, environmental temperatures, not the internal heated tent temperature. We don’t always run the stove overnight and it quickly becomes only a few degrees warmer inside than outside. If you are sleeping next to the tent wall, there can also be condensation here, so a bivvy bag to protect your sleeping bag from moisture is a sensible precaution. I’m also a lot more comfortable knowing I can bivvy without the tent, which could be lost or damaged in a number of ways.
Bivvying out in winter does not necessarily mean you have to be in the northern forest, or even that there is snow on the ground. Winter bivvying can mean spanning a tarp between skeletal trees and waking to a frost on the leaf litter in the morning. Winter bivvying can mean a snow hole cut into windslab in the mountains. Winter bivvying can mean a snow grave dug in soft snow of the boreal forest, lined with spruce boughs. Winter bivvying can mean going to sleep on the green moss of the Arctic forest on a chilly September evening only to find snow on your bivvy bag in the morning. Again there are many varieties of winter bivvy and of course there are differences between them all, some considerable and obvious, others more subtle and nuanced.
There are commonalities for every winter bivvy. Of course we want to get some rest. Keeping warm and staying safe are key objectives, and in winter the two overlap considerably.
Whenever you are sleeping out during the colder months of the year, you should be mindful of the ways in which you lose heat to the environment.
The five mechanisms of heat loss to the environment are convection, conduction, evaporation, respiration and radiation.
Convection, conduction and evaporation and the big three we primarily need to be concerned about while bivvying. Let’s take a look why…
Convection And Winter Bivvying
Convective heat loss occurs between a surface and a moving fluid or gas in contact with it. The air nearest your skin is warmed by the body. If this warm air is allowed to move away from your body, colder air will take its place and you will lose more heat in warming this cold air. To stay warm, you need to trap warm air near your body. It’s the air trapped in your sleep system that keeps you warm, not the material of the sleep system itself.
For a given environmental temperature, you need trap a quantity of air around your body such that it will insulate you against the cold; you need to warm that air with your body heat, without expending too much energy; then you need to keep it there.
This translates to having a sleeping bag with enough loft for the season, fitted with good baffles and drawcords and, if you are outside, a windproof outer bivvy bag. Bivvy bags are not just about keeping dry, they also make your sleeping bag windproof, just as your waterproof jacket helps protect you from cooling effects of wind. The bivvy bag should also be large enough to allow the sleeping bag to loft properly. In winter, this may mean using a bivvy bag which is larger than you would use in summer. Wearing a thermal base layer, socks and a hat will also help trap warm air directly next to your skin.
An allied consideration is keeping your sleeping kit clean. Dirty, greasy sleeping systems, lose some of their insulating properties. Down in sleeping bags can even become matted if dirty enough. Materials may also lose some of their breathability. Keeping your sleeping system clean keeps it effective in protecting you from the environment. This is another good reason for wearing a thermal base layer in your sleeping bag. Alternatively a silk sleeping bag liner is a good investment, particularly to protect expensive down bags. A further benefit of a bivvy bag – at any time of year – is that it keeps dust, dirt and detritus away from the outer surface of your sleeping bag and so also serves to help keep it clean as possible.
Conduction And Winter Bivvying
Heat loss through conduction comes through direct contact with cold surfaces or objects. How quickly heat is transmitted to an object depends on the conductivity of the materials from which the object is made. Metals are generally very good conductors of heat. Air is a poor conductor of heat (hence why it’s so good to have trapped in your sleeping kit). Water conducts heat away from your body about 25 times faster than air. The practical take-away from this fact is that if your clothes or sleeping kit are wet, you will conduct heat into them much more quickly than if they were dry.
The amount of heat you lose to an object depends on how much energy it would take to heat up the object. This, in turn, depends to a large extent on how cold the object is and how large the object is. On a cold day you could warm a small pebble in your hand but you will never warm a large boulder up to your body temperature by getting naked and hugging it! Equally, you are never going to warm up the Earth significantly by lying on it. If you are lying in contact with the ground in winter, or snow, a great deal of heat will be sucked out of you.
The practical take-away is to insulate your body from cold surfaces with a poor conductor. People generally know to use a sleeping mat when camping out. Most people use a sleeping mat because that’s what everyone else does. It’s the advice they were given in the camping store or by their friends. Some campers think it’s just about comfort. The reason most people use a camping mat is not because they’ve tried the alternative of not using one. But if you’ve ever tried sleeping out on the ground without one, you’ll be nodding your head in agreement here in that, even in summer, it’s a cold and unpleasant experience. In severe cold, you can augment your sleeping mat with other equipment such as your rucksack. You can also use natural materials such as spruce boughs if they are available.
Evaporation And Winter Bivvying
To convert a liquid to a vapour or a gas requires energy. In fact it takes a significant amount of energy – more than half a calorie per gram of water evaporated. Hence, evaporation is a very effective mechanism for getting rid of heat. It explains why sweating works so well at keeping you cool on a hot day. The flip side is that if you get wet in a cold environment, you can get very cold, very quickly. The practical take-away is to prevent environmental moisture from coming into contact with your sleeping system.
The environment, however, isn’t the only source of moisture. Even when you are not obviously sweating, your body is always moistening your skin through what is known as insensible perspiration. This occurs even in cold climates. During an 8-hour sleep it’s normal to lose about 350ml of water (an equivalent volume to a can of carbonated drink). Further, when you become too warm, you start to sweat, even during some stages of sleep. Then your clothing or bedding getting wet from sweat can be a bigger problem than water coming in from the environment.
Breathable fabrics, which allow perspiration to escape will help to an extent but you can still get sweaty and damp. Below about -20oC (-4oF) breathable membranes cease to function properly anyway (the water vapour condenses or even freezes before escaping the system).
So the practical take-away here is to minimise moisture production within your sleeping system. This brings us round to respiration.
Respiration And Winter Bivvying
As you breathe cold air, it is warmed before it gets to your lungs. You then breathe out warmed air so you are effectively losing heat every time you breathe. There’s nothing we can do about breathing. Holding our breath is a fairly short-term strategy for conserving heat. It’s a consolation then, that heat loss through breathing is relatively insignificant compared to convection, conduction and evaporation. There is another problem with breathing, though.
A common misconception, when sleeping outside in sub-zero (Celsius) temperatures, is you should put your head inside your sleeping bag to keep your warm breath inside your bag. People also worry about their face becoming too cold. The problem with having your face inside your sleeping bag is the quantity of moisture in your breath. As a result, there will be a significant amount of condensation inside the materials of your sleep system. At best this will cause damp patches in your sleep system, which will make you cold.
In low temperatures, the moisture from your breath will freeze inside your sleeping system. This will, of course, reduce the thermal efficiency of your system during the night. Worse, though, it may be impossible to remove unless you are able to air your sleeping system in a warm cabin or heated tent. The next night you will start from this reduced position, with less thermally efficient sleeping kit. Each night you breath into your sleeping bag, you will make it worse still. It will also become significantly heavier. So, wear a balaclava and breathe outside of your bag!
Radiation And Winter Bivvying
Heat loss from radiation does not occur only from exposed skin. Put another way, even if you are clothed, heat radiates from your body to your clothes, then from your clothes to your surrounding environment. This is a separate mechanism to conduction and convection, which insulating and wind-proof clothing or bedding does a fine job of significantly reducing. Radiating heat does not need a medium such as a conductor or a fluid or a gas. Just think about the heat of the Sun – travelling through the vacuum of space. The outside of your clothing or bedding will be radiating heat to the environment around it, provided the environment is colder, which we are assuming it will be because it is winter.
What is somewhat counter-intuitive is even though you might be a constant temperature, the colder the environment, the more heat you will radiate. It’s the temperature differential between you and the environment which is the determining factor in this equation. There is little you can do about the physical process of radiation but if you minimise the amount of body warmth reaching the outside of your clothing or sleep system through the other mechanisms of heat loss, then you will minimise radiation from your clothing to the surrounding environment. The good news is that radiant heat loss isn’t particularly significant compared to other mechanisms of heat-loss unless you are in a very cold environment, below -30oC to -35oC (below -20oF to -30oF). Despite the efforts of marketers to sell you silvered survival blankets, radiation is the least of your heat-loss worries.
High-Level Heat-Loss Prevention Take-Aways For Winter Bivvying
- Trap plenty of air around your body.
- Make your sleep system wind proof.
- Insulate your body from cold surfaces with a poor conductor.
- Protect your sleeping kit from moisture.
- Keep your sleeping kit clean.
Practical Application In Winter Bivvying
The above points are all well and good but what do we actually do on a practical level to achieve these goals. What routines and protocols do we employ on a day-to-day basis in winter to make sure we maximise the use of our winter bivvy kit. Moreover, what do we do to prevent our sleeping kit degrading over time.
Don’t Scrimp On Sleeping Kit
Your selection of winter bivvy kit isn’t about just having a cosy night’s sleep. In extremis, it could also keep you alive in otherwise fatal conditions. Even if you don’t think you’ll be out in such extreme conditions, being cold and uncomfortable all night means lack of sleep which, in turn, means impaired reasoning, poorer decisions, reduction of attention span, lapses of concentration, impairment of short-term memory and reduced motivation.
In the outdoors none of this is beneficial. I’m sure you could come up with your own scenarios but I need only mention the use of axes or navigating across country in the context of the above effects of sleep deprivation and you understand where I’m coming from. So, make sure your sleeping kit is fit for the conditions, that your sleeping bag is rated for the season, your bivvy bag is large enough to hold your sleeping bag at full loft, that you have a good thermal base layer, hat and socks as well as a decent sleeping mat.
Consider Carefully Where You Set Up
The place you decide to bivvy can have a large bearing on how warm and comfortable your night will be. Warm air is lighter than cold air. Warm air rises, cold air sinks. We were all told this in science class at school. You maybe didn’t realise it at the time but you can now put this knowledge to valuable use in the wilderness to help you stay warm on the coldest of days. This might not surprise you.
What is surprising, however, is how localised cold spots can be. In sub zero temperatures, a small height difference can make a large difference in air temperature. Dropping down only a few feet can plunge you into an a pool of the coldest air in the area. Even in comparatively mild temperatures, dropping down a metre or two (three to six feet) can put in you colder air, which is also much more damp, leaving a heavy dew on you and all your equipment.
So it’s usually best to avoid the lowest ground in the locality. At the other end of the spectrum, seeking out the highest ground is rarely a great idea either. It’s usually more exposed to winds and may be more open to the elements in general. Whether you are digging up a quinzhee or stringing a tarp in the woods, somewhere in between the highest and lowest spots will serve you best. But even then be mindful of the fact that cold air will be literally flowing downhill. I’ve had the unpleasant experience of sleeping in a one-man quinzhee with cold air coming in the opening all night because this aperture was facing uphill on a very, very slight gradient. It was enough to make for a much colder night.
Also think about what is overhead. Just as it is warmer sleeping under a tarp than out in the open, so it is warmer sleeping in the woods, than in an adjacent field. The cover of trees, even deciduous trees devoid of leaves, can make degrees of difference. Indeed it can be frosty out in the fields but not in the woods. Of course, you should also take the usual precautions to look for hung-up windfall, dead tree crowns and other potential widow-makers before setting up camp.
As a final consideration, think about where you might set up so that while you remain sheltered from prevailing weather, you might benefit from the rising sun in the morning, to both warm your body and remove dew or frost from the locality of your camp as well as your kit.
Get The Winter Bivvy Basics Right
Most sleeping bags, especially winter models, come with both a shoulder baffle and a hood draw-cord. Use them. This may sound obvious to the seasoned camper but over the years I have been surprised by the number of people who do not know how to get the most from a sleeping bag. These days I make it part of a short briefing on the foundational courses I teach. Above, I mentioned trapping warm air around your body. The shoulder baffle and associated draw-cord do a very good job of keeping the warm air directly next to your body in place. The draw cord on a sleeping bag hood will also increase heat retention in very cold conditions. I tend to put on a hat before I draw up the hood but the two used in combination reduces the heat lost from your head significantly.
Lars Fält, with whom I had the pleasure of working on a good number of Arctic survival courses had a good way of summarising the next point. He said, when sleeping out in cold conditions, you should have “a lot over you, a lot under you, but little on you.” What he was alluding to was that you should have good insulation under you (your sleeping mat), good insulation over you (your sleeping bag) but shouldn’t wear too many clothes in your sleeping bag. The problem with wearing multiple layers of clothes in a sleeping bag is at some point, should you become too warm, you’ll start to sweat. This perspiration makes both your clothing and your sleeping equipment much more damp than it would otherwise be. And before you tell me you won’t get too warm, the reason it happens often is that people get into their bag already feeling cold, so they keep too many clothes on. Add to this that the sleeping bag feels cold (because it is cold), then people are reluctant to strip down to what they should be wearing. This results in people settling down with too many clothes on and when they do finally warm up, they continue too far the other way, ultimately overheating.
Provided your sleeping bag is properly rated for the season, you have a well-sized bivvy bag and you have a sufficiently insulating mat underneath you, you should be comfortably warm in your sleeping bag wearing only your base layer of thermals, socks and a hat. If conditions do become colder than expected, you can put an outer jacket over the top of your bivvy, like an extra blanket and put on a balaclava as well as your hat. You should carry one with you in winter and have it to hand, ready warmed in your sleeping bag when you go to bed.
Keep finger gloves and mittens inside with you too. This will mean they are not frigid in the morning when you go to put them on. In addition, if you find you have a cold spot on your hip as you lie on your side, then you can slip the gloves or mittens underneath to provide further insulation from the ground or snow underneath. Also in very cold conditions, to look after your feet, in addition to socks, you can wear the felt boot liners from your winter boots, if they have them. If not, consider carrying down or synthetic booties.
To prevent your boots from freezing solid overnight, first brush off any snow from the outside (you can carry a nail brush or vegetable brush for this job) then take the stuff sack from your sleeping bag, turn it inside out and place your boots inside, laying them flat. Then place the sack containing your boots at the bottom of your bivvy bag (another reason you need a bigger bivvy bag for very cold conditions). I often put this under my feet to provide extra separation from the cold underneath me. The boots being inside the sleeping system with you will keep them relatively warm.
Get Warm, Stay Warm
Get into your sleeping bag warm. This may sound obvious but what I mean here is make an intentional effort to be really warm before you get into your bag. If you’ve been outdoors all day, even if you’ve been near a campfire in the evening, you will likely be a little chilly just before bed. Spend five minutes warming up. Walk briskly, jog on the spot, do star jumps or other large muscle-group exercise which will get you warming up. Don’t work to the point where you are sweating (see the point above) bit where you start to feel the heat rising. Your sleeping kit will be at the ambient temperature or not much above it. When you get into it, heat will be transferred from your body to the sleeping bag. If you are already cold, this will make you feel colder and you may well feel cold for hours. Much better to be toasty when you get in and use a little excess heat to warm up your sleeping kit, bringing you back down to normal temperature, thus ensuring a more comfortable night.
Before this, there is something you can do to help stay warm through the night. Have a good meal. If possible, make sure this has a good amount of protein in it, preferably meat. Processing meat is definitely thermogenic. Breaking down proteins also takes some time, so this process will continue for some hours after eating.
You should have a process for getting into your sleeping system quickly and efficiently. This will minimise heat loss to the environment as you get undressed. Have a place for everything you are wearing already pre-planned. Sit on your sleeping kit and sort your boots first. Then taking outer shell layers off and getting into the sleeping system with most upper layers still on works well. I then warm up the sleeping system before removing excess upper body layers. My clothes are used either as a pillow or a blanket over me. In very cold conditions, if you are out in the open, you can put a jacket of your face and breath through the sleeve like an elephant’s trunk. You will certainly have a damp armpit in the morning but it will keep your face warm and the moisture out of your main sleeping system. In getting up in the morning, reverse the process from the night before.
In cold conditions, you may need to pee during the night even if you don’t usually need to get up at home. The cold stress causes you to urinate more. Depending on where you are, a pee bottle can be useful for men but not an option for women. A wide-necked Nalgene bottle or MSR Dromedary works well. If you have to get up, the cold well of a snow shelter is preferable to going outside and you shouldn’t be proud. In a snow grave, you can use the edge of the snow grave, just off the area where you are sleeping. You should be able to stay on your sleeping kit, without needing to retrieve your boots. Depending on the configuration of your sleeping bag and bivvy bag zips, men may even be able to roll onto their sides, unzip and pee from there. While, this might be an unsavoury topic for some, it’s important to have thought this through. Don’t get cold in the middle of the night just because you need a pee. Have a duvet jacket or other warm layer handy – using it as a pillow is ideal – to throw on and keep yourself warm if you have to get out of your sleeping bag. Remember to close the bag up to preserve warmth in the bag.
Keep Your Winter Bivvy Kit Dry
It’s imperative you keep your sleeping kit as dry as possible.Moisture in your sleeping system has several effects. First, there is increased conductive heat loss to wet materials as water conducts heat relatively well.
There is a decrease in insulation if air is either displaced by water or the wetness of materials causes as a collapse in loft (as it certainly will with down fillings, for example). There is increased evaporative heat loss as moisture in the sleep system evaporates and takes heat with it.
Hence, it is critical that you do everything you can keep your sleep system dry. You must keep out environmental moisture. This can be in the form of precipitation, either rain or snow. Dew can also cause significant moisture to accumulate on your kit. A waterproof bivvy bag will form a very effective defence against all these sources of environmental moisture. A bivvy bag also protects your sleeping bag from damp or frozen ground and snow. Even in a snow hole or quinzhee, a bivvy bag is very useful to protect your sleeping bag from all the surrounding snow.
Remember you must also work to minimise the moisture coming from within, either through perspiration or through respiration. Remember not to wear too many clothes and don’t breath into your sleeping bag or bivvy bag. Also, be careful not to introduce snow into your sleeping kit when you get into it in the first place, which will melt and introduce moisture to the system. When in a snow hole or quinzhee it can be somewhat cramped. Sitting up in your sleeping system can be difficult or impossible. It is often awkward getting dressed or undressed. The aim of the game here is to minimise the amount of snow crystals knocked into your sleeping kit or onto your clothing.
Even if you do all of the above, there will be some moisture caught in the system after you spend a night in it. To ensure your sleep system is in as good a condition as possible for the next night, it’s really important to rid the system of as much moisture as possible. If you can, air out your sleeping bag in the morning as soon as possible after you get out of it. At this stage it will still be warm and the warmth will help with evaporation of moisture. If you can get your sleeping kit into morning sunshine, even weak winter sunshine will have enough warmth in it to help drive off moisture.
In cold conditions, bivvy bags can have frost on the inside, so turn them inside out to air them off. Even if it is severely cold, with no direct sunshine, hanging your sleeping kit will likely result in some of the moisture in your sleeping bag frosting on the outside. This can then be beaten off the bag, to remove it. Similarly the frost on the inside of the bivvy bag can be beaten off or shaken off. If the conditions aren’t so cold as to cause moisture to freeze on the surface of the materials, moisture can be reduced with some sun or a breeze or both.
Winter Bivvying – Pulling Everything Together
There are of course nuances and subtleties to each winter bivvy situation. The above general recommendations combined with a good understanding of the fundamental principles of how heat is lost to your environment plus how these apply specifically to the use of a bivvy, sleeping bag and sleeping mat combination, should significantly enhance your winter bivvy experiences if applied diligently. It won’t mean that every winter bivvy experience is a comfortable one, particularly if the bivvy is unplanned and the conditions are extreme. Understanding what you need to do, how to do it and having experience, will stand you in good stead to weather difficult situations and may just save your life.
Let Us Know Your Tales…
Have you had notable or memorable winter bivvying experiences you’d like to recount? Or tips you’d like to share? Let me and other readers know in the comments below.
Related Material On Paul Kirtley;s Blog
Latest posts by Paul Kirtley (see all)
- #AskPaulKirtley 72 – Big Birch Bark Sheets; Deer Carcass Inspection; The Importance Of Tree ID In Bushcraft -
- #AskPaulKirtley 71 – Roycraft Packframes; Sharpening & Oiling Knives; Bow Drill Moisture Content -
- PK Podcast 030: Dr Cassandra Quave On Studying Medicinal Uses Of Plants & The Treatment Of Infectious Disease -