PK Podcast 016: Lisa Fenton On Bushcraft And Indigenous Knowledge Transmissions

by Paul Kirtley

Share it!
Lady with child carrier on her back hiking in Utah

Lisa Fenton during a field research trip in Utah, carrying her son Finn on her back.

My guest on this podcast is Lisa Fenton, who joins me to discuss her research on bushcraft and indigenous knowledge transmissions. Lisa is one of the founders of the Woodsmoke School of Bushcraft and Wilderness Survival, based in the Lake District, in the north west of England. Lisa and her partner Ben McNutt apprenticed with Ray Mears in the late 1990s and early 2000s before going on to set up Woodsmoke together in 2001.

In 2006 Lisa’s interest in anthropology and ethnobotany led her to enrol in a masters degree in ethnobotany offered by Kent University in conjunction with Kew Gardens. Lisa obtained her MSc in 2008, gaining a ‘distinction’ for her final thesis on British wild plant foods. Lisa followed this by reading for a PhD in ethnobiology at Kent University’s School of Anthropology and Conservation, which she has recently completed, gaining her doctorate.

Dr Fenton’s research area was ‘Bushcraft and Indigenous Knowledge Transmissions’, her work examining the relationship between Bushcraft and indigenous knowledge. Lisa’s research was supervised by the distinguished anthropologist Prof. Roy Ellen and comprised an historical review, an examination of ethnographic literature, field work in multiple locations, including Sweden the UK and the USA, in addition to interviewing professional Bushcraft instructors and surveying those who use Bushcraft as part of their outdoor leisure pursuits.

Case studies of several iconic aspects of Bushcraft including the figure-4 deadfall trap and fire-by-friction were used to explore a number of themes in the contemporary Bushcraft world. I was keen to invite Lisa onto this podcast to find out more about her academic work and the unique perspectives she’s gained from her research.

Lisa Fenton with San tribe member

Lisa in Namibia in 2003.

We cover a good amount of ground and we dig deep into the history and origins of Bushcraft as we know it today, its relationship with indigenous knowledge, modern camping as well as survival and survivalism. Our conversation forms Episode 16 of the Paul Kirtley Podcast…

How To Listen To This Podcast

You can listen to this podcast here on my website by using the player above. Just press the play button on the right of the player.

You can download the podcast episode .mp3 file by right-clicking on the download icon just to the left of the play button to save the .mp3 file down to your local machine/device.

You can also subscribe on iTunes and on Stitcher or via my podcast-only RSS feed.

TRANSCRIPT

Click here to read or download the transcript of Episode 16 of The Paul Kirtley Podcast

Links

Ethnobotany MSc at University of Kent
Royal Botanic Gardens Kew
University of Kent School of Anthropology & Conservation

Contact Lisa Fenton

http://www.woodsmoke.uk.com/contact/

Lisa Fenton instructing wild plants in Cumbria

Lisa teaching in the English Lake District, where she is based.

Lisa Fenton in snow in Maine, USA

Lisa on a north woods adventure in Maine.

Thanks For Listening!

Thanks for joining me on this podcast. If you have any comments about this episode, please leave them in the comments section below.

If you enjoyed this episode, please share it using the social media buttons at the top of this page. Thanks!

And Finally… May I Ask A Favour?

If you haven’t done already, please, please leave an honest review & rating on iTunes or on Stitcher.

Ratings and reviews are extremely helpful and greatly appreciated! They do matter in the rankings of this podcast, they help get this content in front of other people who would benefit from what it contains. AND I read each and every one of them.

Related Material On Paul Kirtley’s Blog

PK Podcast 010: Alyssa Crittenden On The Hadza, Honey And The Human Diet

PK Podcast 007: Jules Pretty, Travels With Enduring People In Vanishing Lands

The Difference Between Foraging and Living Off The Land: Bushcraft Show 2013 Presentation

Favourite Films: Cree Hunters Of Mistassini

The following two tabs change content below.
Paul Kirtley is an award-winning professional bushcraft instructor. He is passionate about nature and wilderness travel. In addition to writing this blog Paul owns and runs Frontier Bushcraft, a wilderness bushcraft school, offering bushcraft courses and wilderness expeditions.

 

{ 31 comments… read them below or add one }

kevin

Fascinating. Possibly the best discussion on ALL aspects of ‘bushcraft’ I’ve ever listened to – particularly the latter 20 minutes. Thank you very much. I actually wanted to go straight back to the start and listen to it again. Is it actually possible to read a copy of Lisa’s thesis anywhere?
Regards,
Kevin

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Hi Kevin,

Thanks for your positive feedback on this episode. I’m very gratified you found it so valuable.

As far as I know Lisa’s thesis is not yet publicly available but I have dropped her a message to ask if it will be at some stage.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Hi Kevin,

Thank you for you comments. I am very keen for the research so be put into the public domain and as such am beginning to work towards publishing the thesis.

I am advised by my academic colleagues that the work has opened a new field of academic enquiry, which is exciting for the future of Bushcraft, and which motivates me to work towards publishing :)!

I hope this helps. Kind regards,
Lisa

Reply

Kevin

Hi Lisa,
Thanks for taking the time to reply. I really look forward to seeing it. It crosses my mind that it would make a fantastic subject for a documentary series, combining history, philosophy and ethno/anthropology in a really accessible (and increasingly popular) subject. Perhaps someone should contact the BBC!

Personally, the one message that really hit home for me was the comparison between survivalism and bushcraft, i.e. running away from nature and running toward nature – hate/love. I wonder if there are parallels with the movements of the 60s/70s and the Cold War? It is also interesting that the main survivalist core appears to be in the USA, where bushcraft is often portrayed as an additional skillset (along with firearms of course) to help you survive and get back to civilisation; whereas in Europe, bushcraft strikes me as being more separate and about getting back toward a more ecological, holistic way of life and away from technology. Fear of the system and dissatisfaction with the system perhaps.

Enough already! I could talk for hours on the subject!

Thanks again for bringing bushcraft to a new intellectual level 🙂

Best regards,
Kevin

Reply

Chris Eyles

Really looking forward to listening to this – have downloaded it to enjoy once the week’s madness has subsided.

Lisa’s articles in The Bushcraft Magazine are something I’ve enjoyed a lot in the past.

Also enjoyed your “gig” onstage at The Bushcraft Show” Paul.

Can’t help but think that you should have done an “Ask Paul Kirtley” instead though.

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Hi Chris,

The thought of doing a live #AskPaulKirtley did cross my mind but in the end I wanted to deliver a keynote with a bigger and more far-reaching message.

I think there will be some further opportunities to do live Q&A sessions. And if I’m back at the Bushcraft Show next year, I’ll look at a way of including one while I’m there.

Glad you enjoyed the talk on Sunday. I really appreciate you coming to listen to what I had to say.

I’m sure you’ll enjoy the conversation between myself and Lisa too.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Chris Eyles

Hi Paul

I listened to this whilst out on a long walk yesterday. I normally don’t indulge in using tech whilst out and about, but there was a long ugly boring bit that I needed to get through and listening to this podcast was a great remedy to that.

I really enjoyed it, lots to think about, so thanks to you both.

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Hi Chris,

Glad we were able to keep you company and easy the boring/ugly bit.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Thanks Chris…it’s a pleasure

Best
Lisa

Reply

paul russell

One of my favourite podcasts so far. What a stimulating interview with such broad topic coverage.
Thank you so much to Dr Fenton and Mr Kirtly for giving me such an enjoyable hour and forty five minutes.

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Our pleasure Paul. Thanks for your feedback. I’m glad you enjoyed it so much.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Thank you Paul, so glad you enjoyed it 🙂

Best,
Lisa

Reply

Fred Ernst

Still would like you to see you interject with your guests more Paul on these podcasts more frequently with your expertise to make the podcast flow more interestingly for your audience. Essentially challenge them more. I see many opportunities for you.

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Hi Fred,

Thanks for your feedback. I make a conscious effort not to interrupt people but I take your comments onboard and will integrate them going forwards.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Kevin Baldwin

It’s all been said above Paul! Fascinating, highly stimulating – one of the most interesting to date. The documentry idea may be worth exploring for someone. There’s certainly a wealth of material there to use.

Thank you once again for your efforts in bringing us these podcasts.

Kev

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Hi Kevin,

Great to hear that you enjoyed the podcast so much. We only touched superficially on a few of the areas covered in the research….so there is a LOT more rich and interesting material that the research raised and delved into. It was a fascinating journey in bringing it all together to understand the subject at quite a deep philosophical level. It was really enjoyable to be able to chat about it a bit…thanks Paul!

Kind regards
Lisa

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Hi Kevin,

It’s my pleasure to bring these podcasts to the wider world. But thank you for your feedback. It’s motivational to know these sessions are appreciated.

Take care and warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Craig Longstaff

FANTASTIC podcast Paul and Lisa. Thank you.

Whilst you talked alot about academia, you presented it in laymans terms (simplicity) for the likes of me.

H.O.O.R.A.Y. that someone has at last had the courage to identify and talk of how we (our ‘bushcraft’ ancestors) unethically facilitated in (and are thus complicit in) the cancerous growth of Big Pharma, Big Business and Big Government / Society through our ‘forbearers’ abuse of indigenous people to “survive”. It really is a crime against humanity that our colonial imperialist “explorer”, “adventurer” and “pioneer” forbearers exploited, manipulated, ‘raped and pillaged’ the knowledge, skills, resources and good will of indigenous peoples around the world in bygone times to meet their own egotistical and commercial ends.

The current ‘bushcraft’ community now owe it to indigenous people to protect them, their ways and their communities. WE ALL would do well to remember that indigenous people are the lifeblood of modern society; only an arrogant and egotistical fools (like many of our “educated” ancestors) will forget this and/or think otherwise. We are forever indebted to indigenous people for their knowledge, skills and resources, and need to start halting and reversing the destruction being wreaked by Big Pharma, Big Business, and Big Government / Society.

Interesting too, the link Lisa made between military and ‘bushcraft’. The current Scouts and Guides movements originally stem from the military – if people do their research, the Scouts in effect, albeit more subtly and clandestinely, were set up to recruit and grooming “child soldiers” of the time…a very uncomfortable truth. Gladly today, things are very different.

Fab podcast. I’ve yet to learn to download it to my phone (have tried and tried, lol).

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Hi Craig, and thanks :)!

Indeed, there are a lot of layers to this subject, and some of them very politically uncomfortable, but we can only move towards decolonisation by first understanding the processes and consequences of colonisation so as not to repeat it in our personal practice and in the practice of contemporary bushcraft more broadly. This is where I feel we need to be very careful of the militaristic aspects (at an ideological level) that are being extolled by popular media entertainment, so that many people think survivalism is bushcraft and vice versa when in fact they are not.

Thanks for your insightful comments,

Best wishes
Lisa

Reply

Dave Welsby

Congratulations Paul! This was a brilliant episode, I even downloaded the transcript so I could read over it and do some more research. For me bushcraft is definitely to be more self reliant, I’m always researching how to take thinks to a more basic level. I need a pot, how did they make them before steel, so on and so forth. Not that I’m against using modern technology, I just want the understanding and skill in case it’s not at hand.
Thanks again and best regards!

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Cheers Dave 🙂

Reply

Mark H

Thank you Lisa and Paul,

An amazing podcast rich in many ‘veins of thought’ and philosophy.

The subject of ‘Bushcraft’ and the study of it is constantly creating avenues of understanding and opportunity at so many levels.

Connecting people with their natural surroundings , connecting us with our past , putting our lives in to perspective , creating moral boundaries , providing life affirming experiences , re igniting the spark for learning , forging new levels of confidence and self worth..I guess the list of positives attributable to this subject is ‘endless’.

Two strong themes come through. Lisa’s academic focus on the subject is both insightful and provocative and yet very relaxed. As a listener I felt compelled to hear what she had to say.
Secondly that this subject is all about making sense of nature and our place within it and realising how positive that relationship is.

Once again thank you Lisa and Paul a quality podcast.

Best Regards

Mark

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Thanks for your feedback Mark. Glad you found it stimulating.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Thanks for such great feedback Mark…I think you hit the nail, especially when you say that ultimately it’s ‘all about making sense of nature and our place within it and realising how positive that relationship is.’ There is so much to explore with Bushcraft and with its relationship to Indigenous knowledge of Land to further understanding our human relationships to the natural world through skill, knowledge and participation with it.

Best!
Lisa

Reply

Dean

Thanks Paul(& Lisa)

Thoroughly enjoyed that,well conducted interview.
To hear someone speak with such knowledge and passion is a privilege.
Warm Regards
Dean

Reply

Paul Kirtley

I’m very glad you enjoyed this Dean.

Thanks for your feedback.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Thanks Dean :)!

Reply

Scott

I really enjoyed this, thank you. One piece of constructive criticism if I may – I listened to the podcast, and found the little noises you made really quite distracting, umm hmm and so on – I know it’s instinctive but in broadcasting terms it is probably a habit worth breaking (you wouldn’t catch Melvyn Bragg doing it on In Our Time, for example) – better to let whoever is speaking have the ‘airwaves’ to themselves

Reply

Paul Kirtley

Hi Scott,

Thanks for taking the time to leave a comment. I appreciate your feedback and yes, I do have a habit of making these affirmatory noises. I try to structure these as conversations rather than interviews and with some guests it helps to keep it very relaxed in this fashion. But yes, I take your point and will do my best to minimise the distraction in future.

Warm regards,

Paul

Reply

Lisa Fenton

Glad you enjoyed the conversation Scott!

Reply

Al

Enjoyed this podcast very much!
Keep Your Tinder Dry

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: